A signature made with a finger on a tablet is a simple electronic signature: it is nothing more than that, and the law does not throw it away. Under the European eIDAS Regulation a judge cannot refuse an electronic signature as evidence just because it is electronic. The Italian Digital Administration Code adds that, for a simple signature, the value of the document is assessed case by case. It is worth as much as you can prove around the signature: who signed, what they signed, when.
Anyone who wants to remove paper from the practice therefore has two questions: what the law requires for the form of consent, and how to hold up a simple signature. The rules answer the first, what you can do in the record answers the second. On your form, the opinion that counts is that of the practice's lawyer.
What Italian Law 219/2017 requires as to form
Article 1 of Italian Law 219/2017 (opens in a new tab) states, in paragraph 4, that informed consent is documented «in written form or through video recordings» (or, for a person with a disability, with devices that allow them to communicate) and that, in whatever form it is expressed, it goes into the clinical record. It does not name any type of signature and does not mention paper or digital. It requires that consent be documented and that it be in the record.
The Code of Medical Ethics (opens in a new tab) goes in the same direction: in article 35 consent is obtained in written and signed form «or with other methods of equivalent documentary efficacy» in the cases provided for. The required form therefore leaves room for digital, and the question shifts to how well the electronic signature you use holds up if someone contests it.
The three electronic signatures of the eIDAS Regulation
Regulation (EU) 910/2014 (opens in a new tab), in its consolidated text, distinguishes three levels.
| Signature | What it is, under the Regulation | Legal effect |
|---|---|---|
| Electronic (simple) | Data in electronic form, connected to other data, used by the signatory to sign (art. 3) | Its effect and its admissibility as evidence cannot be denied solely because it is electronic (art. 25, para. 1) |
| Advanced | An electronic signature uniquely connected to the signatory, which identifies them, created with data the signatory can use under their exclusive control and linked to the signed data in such a way that any subsequent change is detectable (art. 26) | The same article 25, paragraph 1 applies. In Italy the CAD gives it the effect of a private written document (art. 20, paragraph 1-bis) |
| Qualified | An advanced signature created with a qualified device and based on a qualified certificate (art. 3) | Legal effect equivalent to that of a handwritten signature (art. 25, para. 2) |
The row we are interested in is the first. A finger signature on a tablet, which saves the image of the stroke, belongs to that level. To be advanced a signature must meet all four requirements of article 26, and the image of a stroke on a tablet is not made to demonstrate them: Fibonacci treats it as a simple signature. The Regulation does not say it is useless. It says it cannot be discarded because it is electronic.
What this means for consent on a tablet
The CAD completes the picture in Italy. An electronic document with a simple signature does not automatically have the effect of a private written document: the judge assesses it on the basis of its security, integrity and immutability. In a dispute, the signature on the tablet is not enough on its own and is not discarded either. What counts is what surrounds it.
This means the traces are worth more than the signature. The things that can be kept together with the signature, and that a judge can look at, are these:
- Who signed. The identity document checked beforehand, and the name of the doctor who checked it.
- Where. A signature taken in the practice, with the patient in front of you, holds up more than one taken remotely with no one watching.
- What they read. The signed text must be the same text the patient had in front of them. If you change a word afterwards, the signature cannot be carried over to the new text.
- When. Date and time, recorded by someone who cannot change them by hand.
- What happened afterwards. The unchangeable document, with revocations written alongside and not in place of the original text.
None of these things turns a simple signature into an advanced one. They serve to ensure that, if someone contests it, you do not have only an image of a scribble.
How Fibonacci works
Fibonacci offers two routes for the patient's signature, today.
Finger signature on the tablet. The patient signs in a box, can erase and redo, then confirms. Fibonacci saves only the image of the signature: it does not record pressure, speed or timings of the stroke, so it is not a graphometric signature and does not store biometric data. The signature is linked to the text the patient approved, and in the consent PDF the image appears with the time and the sentence stating how it was collected. Fibonacci calls it what it is, a simple electronic signature. In the event of a dispute the judge assesses it case by case, and that is why it matters that the patient signs in the practice, with the document already checked.
Signature on paper and scan. If the patient does not want the tablet, the procedure prints the consent already filled in, with the lines for the two signatures and the fingerprint of the text at the bottom. It is signed in pen, confirmed and the scan attached. As long as the scan is missing the consent remains flagged as «signed on paper, scan to be attached», so it is not forgotten.
The signature with a code the patient receives on their phone is coming. We are not counting it among today's routes.
The signed consent cannot be modified. If the technique changes a new consent is prepared, and the previous ones remain in the history. Revocation remains written alongside the original document, never in its place. Every operation goes into the access log, which states who did what and when.
If the patient asks for a copy
The signed consent remains in the record and you can download it again as a PDF identical to the one archived. If the patient area is active in your practice, signed consents are visible to the patient as standard: they can review them, and you do not have to send them by hand. On copies of the clinical record, in general, there is a separate article.
What we cannot tell you
How a judge will assess a consent with a simple signature depends on the case: it is the rule itself that leaves the assessment to them.
What you can do is reduce what surrounds the signature to controllable things: a verified identity, a text that does not change, a time that is not written by hand, a log of accesses. That is why it is worth having patients sign in the practice and not from home, and the time the patient has to decide is another topic: you will find it in an article on time to decide.




