When a patient asks for a copy of the record, you have two legal references with two different time limits. Italian Law 24/2017 (opens in a new tab) speaks of seven days, but it is addressed to the health management of a facility. The GDPR sets one month, extendable, and applies to every data controller, so also to your practice. The copy is free the first time, in electronic format if the request arrived electronically, and must be accompanied by certain information on the processing of data.
Below, the two texts read article by article, what you hand over, what you do not hand over without thinking first, and what to write in the record.
The two legal bases
Italian Law 24/2017: seven days, for facilities
Article 4, paragraph 2, establishes that the health management of the public or private facility, within seven days of the submission of the request by the entitled data subjects, provides the available health documentation relating to the patient, preferably in electronic format. Any additions must in any case be provided within a maximum of thirty days from the request.
The text speaks of facility and health management. Whether it also applies to a doctor working alone, in a practice without a health management, the provision does not say. So the prudent choice is this: treat the seven days as the target and the GDPR month as the limit that applies to any controller. A patient who waits three weeks for a document you have in a drawer is unlikely to find it reasonable.
The GDPR: one month, and not just the copy
Article 15 (opens in a new tab) gives the data subject the right to obtain confirmation as to whether or not processing of their data is taking place, access to the data and a series of information: the purposes, the categories of data, the recipients, the envisaged retention period (or the criteria for determining it), the existence of the rights of rectification, erasure, restriction, objection, the right to lodge a complaint with the Garante. Paragraph 3 adds that the controller shall provide «a copy of the personal data undergoing processing». Paragraph 4 says that the right to obtain a copy must not adversely affect the rights and freedoms of others.
The Code of Medical Ethics, for the part concerning the doctor, says that the doctor must make the clinical documentation in their possession, in the exclusive interest of the person assisted, available to that person or to doctors and institutions indicated by them in writing (art. 25).
What you hand over
The typical request is «I want a copy of my record». To respond well you need to read it with the words of Article 15: the data, and the information on the processing. A checklist:
- Personal details and medical history
- Visits, assessments and treatments (product, batch, areas, quantity)
- Prescriptions, tests and reports
- Signed consents, including any that have been withdrawn
- Clinical photographs
- Access log for the record, if requested
- The information under art. 15, para. 1: purposes, categories, recipients, retention period, rights, complaint
- A note on what is not included and why, if something is not handed over
In Fibonacci, from the Altro menu of the patient's record, Esporta PDF produces a document with personal details, medical history, treatments, prescriptions, tests, consents and the access log, and it is the copy to hand over for access (art. 15). Esporta CSV gives the same content in a spreadsheet. Esporta in FHIR downloads an archive with the data in the FHIR standard, the photographs, the reports and a file with the fingerprint of each file (exports and patient rights). The photos are encrypted in storage and are decrypted in the ZIP at the time of export, so that the patient receives images they can open. The right to portability (art. 20) has its own conditions, including being based on consent or a contract and on automated processing: it is not something that «triggers» with every request for a copy.
What you do not hand over without thinking
Paragraph 4 of Article 15 protects the rights of others. In a record there may be something concerning a third party (a family member, a companion): assess it before handing it over. And a request for erasure has nothing to do with a request for a copy: they are two different rights, and the erasure of clinical documentation is not automatic.
Is the person asking who they say they are?
If you have reasonable doubts about the identity of the person making the request, Article 12, paragraph 6, allows you to request further information to confirm it. For a patient you know, this is not needed; for a request that arrives from an email address you have never seen, it is.
Cost and format
Article 12, paragraph 5, says that communications and actions on the data subject's rights are free of charge. A reasonable fee may be charged if the requests are manifestly unfounded or excessive, in particular because of their repetitive character (and the burden of demonstrating this is yours), or, under Article 15, paragraph 3, for further copies. The format: if the request arrives electronically, and unless the patient indicates otherwise, the information must be provided in a commonly used electronic format.
If you do not intend to act on the request, you must inform the data subject without delay, and at the latest within one month, of the reasons and of the possibility of lodging a complaint with the supervisory authority and of a judicial remedy (art. 12, para. 4).
What to record about the request
The Code of Medical Ethics (art. 26) requires that the record be drawn up with completeness, clarity and diligence, and that corrections be justified and signed. The request for a copy and the handover are not clinical data, but it is worth having them written down somewhere, because it is worth being able to demonstrate that you responded, and when:
- date and channel of the request (email, PEC, in person), and who made it;
- how you verified identity, if you had doubts;
- what you handed over (list of documents), in what format, by what means and on what date;
- if you extended the time limits, the reason and when you communicated it;
- if you did not hand something over, the reason.
The order of handover also matters: if the practice closes or you change software, you export everything, check that the package has been received, and only then proceed to erasure. The practice is the one responding to requests, as data controller: Fibonacci provides the tools.
A template response
Sample text, with fictitious data, to be adapted. It is not a statutory form.
Dear Ms [name], in response to your request of [date], we enclose a copy of your clinical documentation held at our practice, in [PDF/electronic] format, including [list: visits, treatments, consents, photographs, reports]. We remind you that your data are processed for [purposes], that we retain them for [period or criteria], that you may request the rectification of inaccurate data and that you may lodge a complaint with the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali. [If something is not handed over: reason.]
What matters, in the template, is that it contains the date of the request, the list of documents, the information under Article 15 and the possibility of complaint.
Mistakes that happen
- Sending photos by ordinary messaging. They are health data: the channel must be chosen accordingly (photos in the record).
- Replying only «here is the record» without the information under Article 15.
- Letting the month pass without writing anything. The extension is communicated within the first month, with the reasons.
- Confusing the copy with erasure. Each is answered for what it is.
The guide the patient asks for a copy of the record covers the same topic in brief. How long the record is retained is in the article on retention, and the reference page on the site is the incomplete record.




