Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Consent and legal protection

Informed consent in aesthetic medicine: what it must contain and how it is documented

Informed consent in aesthetic medicine: what Italian Law 219/2017 says, what the patient must know and how to prove that you informed them.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 12 min read

A hand signing a document with a pen
In this article
  1. What Italian Law 219/2017 says
  2. What the patient must receive
  3. Who obtains it
  4. One consent for each treatment
  5. How to prove that the information was given
  6. The signature
  7. Minors
  8. Refusal and revocation
  9. What changes when consent is in the practice management system
  10. What consent does not do

Informed consent is not the signed form: it is the information the patient receives before deciding, and the form is the proof that you gave it. Under Italian Law 219/2017 (opens in a new tab) no medical treatment may be started without the person's free and informed consent, and the consent must be documented and placed in the clinical record. In aesthetic medicine it weighs more, because the treatment is a choice and not a necessity: the patient must know what can be achieved, what can go wrong and what happens if they do nothing.

Three things are often confused in forms: what the law says, what the information in aesthetics must contain, and what to keep in order to be able to prove you gave it. They must be kept separate. For an assessment of your form you need the practice's lawyer.

What Italian Law 219/2017 says

The law has only one article that directly concerns your practice, the first. The parts you need in practice are five.

Paragraph 1: no treatment without consent. Treatment cannot be started or continued if free and informed consent is missing, except in the cases provided for by law. «Continued» matters: a course of sessions cannot rest on a consent taken at the first one.

Paragraph 3: what the patient has the right to know. Every person has the right to be informed «in a complete, up-to-date and comprehensible manner» about the diagnosis, prognosis, benefits and risks of the proposed treatments, the possible alternatives and the consequences of refusal. The patient may also refuse to receive the information or name a trusted person to receive it on their behalf: in that case the refusal, or the appointment, is recorded in the clinical record.

Paragraph 4: the form. Consent is «obtained in the ways and with the tools most suited to the patient's condition» and is documented in written form, by video recording or, for a person with a disability, with devices that allow them to communicate. In whatever form it is expressed, it goes into the clinical record. The law does not specify a type of signature: it requires that the consent remains documented.

Paragraph 5: refusal and revocation. A capable patient may refuse a treatment or revoke consent already given at any time, in the same forms as paragraph 4, even when the revocation entails the interruption of the treatment. Acceptance, revocation and refusal are noted in the clinical record.

Paragraph 8: the conversation is treatment time. The time of communication between doctor and patient constitutes treatment time. This also applies to the consultation visit that does not end in a treatment.

One caveat remains in the same article, at paragraph 11: special rules governing consent for certain acts or treatments remain in force. Consent for a procedure that has its own discipline (a device with its own requirements, a medicine used off-label) may require something more. We cover this in the dedicated articles.

One thing the law does not do: it does not list the items of a form and does not set a number of days for reflection. Article 1 sets out the contents of the information (paragraph 3) and the form (paragraph 4). The rest, in a form, is built by whoever writes it.

What the patient must receive

Paragraph 3 provides the skeleton: diagnosis, prognosis, benefits, risks, alternatives, consequences of refusal. The Code of Medical Deontology (opens in a new tab) at Article 33 requires information that is «comprehensible and exhaustive», suited to the person's capacity for understanding, and states that the doctor responds to every request for clarification. It adds the foreseeable risks and complications and the behaviours the patient will have to follow afterwards.

For aesthetic treatments the Code has a dedicated article, 76 bis, devoted to aesthetic medicine. It states that the doctor, in the information that precedes the written consent, neither raises nor feeds illusory expectations, identifies the possible alternatives of equal efficacy and works to ensure the maximum safety of the procedures. Anyone reading «alternatives of equal efficacy» thinks of the form: a line saying «the alternatives were discussed» is not enough to make them appear.

A review published in Open Medicine (2018) on information in aesthetic treatments reconstructs how the Italian Court of Cassation has dealt with the subject. What it reports is useful for understanding where the risk is concentrated:

  • the information must be exhaustive, detailed, comprehensible and must also include the less probable adverse events, because the treatment is optional and there is no clinical necessity that justifies keeping silent;
  • it concerns not only the improvement achievable, but also the risk of a worsening of the starting appearance;
  • according to the review, if an aesthetic procedure leaves a blemish worse than the one to be removed and the patient had not been fully informed of the negative effects, the judges presumed that they would not have given consent (Cass. civ., sez. III, no. 12830/2014);
  • the patient must also be informed about the organisation of the facility where the treatment is carried out, for example about missing equipment or staff.

It is a review article, not a judgment: if you want the text of a decision, you have to look it up by number. It serves to understand which items the judge goes looking for.

Understanding is verified, not presumed

The StatPearls entry on informed consent recalls that consent is a process of communication and not a signature, and that among the elements to be documented is an assessment of how much the patient has understood. It also indicates a practical method, «teach-back»: ask the patient to explain back to you in their own words what you will do and what risks there are. Italian guidelines do not prescribe it, but it is a simple way to have something to write in the record that is not just «informed». The same text flags a recurring problem: forms written at a reading level too high for those who receive them.

Who obtains it

Article 35 of the Code is clear: obtaining consent or dissent is an act within the specific and exclusive competence of the doctor, not delegable. The doctor does not undertake or continue diagnostic procedures or therapeutic interventions without prior informed consent. The Code requires consent in written and signed form, or with other methods of equivalent documentary value, in the cases provided for by the legal system and by the Code and in those with high risk or with outcomes that significantly affect psycho-physical integrity.

In a practice with a reception desk that has the forms signed before the visit, this is the point to keep in mind. The reception staff can hand over the form, prepare the data, explain where to sign. The information and the obtaining of consent remain the doctor's.

Paragraph 1 speaks of «no treatment»: consent is tied to what is about to be done. A single form for the whole practice («I consent to aesthetic medicine treatments») says little about the risks and alternatives of a toxin, a filler, a laser. This is the case of generic consent, where your proof is weaker. How to set up a consent for each session is covered in one consent for each treatment.

The practical rule that follows: name of the treatment, area, product or technique, risks specific to that treatment, alternatives, expected result and what cannot be guaranteed. When something substantial changes (another area, another technique, another product), a new consent is drawn up.

How to prove that the information was given

To prove means to be able to reconstruct, years later, what happened in that room. The signed form is one part of the proof. The others you write yourself in the clinical record.

A checklist to keep to hand during the visit:

  • Date and time of the information, and name of the doctor who gave it
  • Proposed treatment, area and technique, in words the patient understands
  • Expected benefits and realistic result (including the risk of not improving)
  • Risks of the treatment, including the less probable ones
  • Alternatives, including doing nothing
  • What was handed to the patient in writing (the form, the after-treatment instructions)
  • Questions asked by the patient and answers given
  • How you verified that they understood
  • How much time they had to decide, and whether they decided straight away or came back
  • Signed consent, with the date, and the doctor's signature
  • Any refusal of information or named trusted person (paragraph 3)

An example of a clinical record line, with fictional data:

Visit of 12/03, 10.15. Example patient, 41 years old. Proposal: botulinum toxin, forehead and glabella. Informed of the expected result, the possibility of asymmetry or insufficient effect, onset time and duration, alternative of not treating. Asked about the difference between two products: explained. Repeated the main risks in their own words. Form handed over and read in the practice, signed on 12/03. Session scheduled for 19/03.

A line like this does not replace the form: it explains that the form was preceded by a conversation. And it ties the signature to a visit, not to a sheet that fell out of a folder.

The signature

On what type of signature is needed, Law 219 says nothing: it says that the consent is documented. A pen signature on paper, scanned and stored, is documentation. A signature on a tablet, which records the image of the stroke with date and time, is documentation. How an electronic signature is assessed in the event of a dispute is a subject in itself, which we cover in consent signed on a tablet. Here the principle is enough: the more traces linked to the moment (identity document checked, presence in the practice, text identical to the one read), the better the signature holds up.

Minors

For a minor, consent is given or refused by the parents or the guardian, taking into account the will of the minor in relation to their age and degree of maturity (Italian Law 219/2017, Article 3, paragraph 2). The minor has the right to receive information suited to their capacities. The Code of Deontology goes in the same direction at Articles 33 and 35, and 76 bis states that aesthetic procedures aimed at minors or incapacitated persons comply with the legal system. The case has its own rules and its own article: minor patient in aesthetic medicine.

Refusal and revocation

The patient can say no, even after signing. Paragraph 5 is clear: consent can be revoked at any time, in the same forms, and the revocation must be noted in the clinical record. The doctor respects the patient's wish to refuse or to give up the treatment and, for this reason, is not liable in civil or criminal law for the choice (paragraph 6). The same paragraph also states that the patient cannot demand treatments contrary to provisions of law, to professional deontology or to good clinical-care practice: faced with such a request, the doctor has no obligations.

Revoking a consent does not erase the document. The signed consent, with its revocation, remains in the clinical record: it is what says what was decided and when.

A management system does not make a consent valid: it makes it easier to find and less easy to lose. This is what Fibonacci does.

  • The consent is generated from a template, which can be one of the proprietary templates or one of your own practice's (for example your scientific society's form, which you upload yourself). The proprietary templates are drafts: the clinical content has not been validated by a healthcare lawyer or by a doctor in the discipline, and must be reviewed by you before use.
  • Before saving, you re-read the text section by section and tick it off item by item. For a proprietary template you also declare that you have read it and adopted it as your own: the declaration remains in the consent, with the text's fingerprint, the doctor and the time.
  • Allergies, current therapies and comorbidities must be declared in the data step, even with «none».
  • A template with points still to be completed (for example the expected result or the risks) does not reach the signature.
  • The patient signs in the practice: with a finger on the tablet, which saves the image of the signature and does not record pressure or speed of the stroke, or on paper, with the scan attached to the clinical record. Until the scan is there, the consent remains flagged.
  • A signed consent is not modified. If the technique changes, a new consent is prepared, and the previous ones remain in the history. The revocation remains written next to the original document.
  • A session recorded without a signed consent does not disappear: it is recorded anyway, and remains flagged as lacking consent. What has been done is not hidden.
  • No consent text is written by artificial intelligence: the patient signs the text of a template that you have read and adopted.

The features are on the informed consents and clinical record pages. The informed consents page of the website explains the six items a form must have, and the legal protection on consent page gathers the rules and judgments. If you are starting from the visit, the guide to the first visit shows where consent fits in the sequence.

A well-made consent does not guarantee the outcome of a case: none of the sources states so. A text to copy does not exist, because the clinical content (risks, percentages, alternatives) is decided by you with the guidelines of your scientific society. And the practice's form still needs to be read by the lawyer.

What remains, if you want to start from a single point: for every treatment, write in the clinical record what you said, to whom, when, and how you understood that it had been understood. The signed sheet comes afterwards.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The consent catalogue in Fibonacci

Sources

  1. Italian Law 22 December 2017, no. 219, art. 1 and art. 3 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  2. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, arts. 33, 35 and 76 bis (opens in a new tab)
  3. The Central Importance of Information in Cosmetic Surgery and Treatments (Open Medicine, 2018) (opens in a new tab)
  4. StatPearls, Informed Consent (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles