Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Consent and legal protection

How much time the patient must have to decide: delivering information before the day of treatment

Reflection time before an aesthetic treatment: Italian Law 219/2017 sets no number of days, but the Code requires information before written consent. What to record.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 6 min read

Hand holding a wooden hourglass
In this article
  1. What the rules say
  2. What the literature says
  3. Why time weighs when someone challenges you
  4. Time in practice at the clinic
  5. What the patient does at home and what they confirm at the clinic
  6. How to note a refusal or a change of mind
  7. A checklist

The law does not set a number of days between the information and the treatment. There are, however, two things written down. Italian Law 219/2017 says that the time of communication between doctor and patient is time of care, and the Code of Medical Ethics requires that the information precede the written consent. The form handed to the patient in the waiting room, a minute before going in, complies with the letter of the law and little else.

Anyone with a tight schedule thinks of time as a cost. The sources treat it as part of the information: a consent taken in a hurry is easier to challenge than one taken after a conversation and a period to think it over. Below: what the rules say, what the literature suggests, and how to document a period of time that nobody obliges you to give but that it is worth being able to prove you gave.

What the rules say

Italian Law 219/2017. Paragraph 3 of article 1 requires information that is «complete, up to date and comprehensible» on diagnosis, benefits, risks and alternatives. Information of that kind is not given in two minutes, and paragraph 8 recognises that the time spent giving it is time of care, not time wasted. Paragraph 5 says that the patient may refuse or revoke consent at any time.

Code of Medical Ethics. Article 76 bis (opens in a new tab), on aesthetic medicine, speaks of «information preliminary to written consent»: the information comes before the form. Article 33 requires information suited to the person's capacity to understand and says that the doctor responds to every request for clarification. Article 35 requires consent to be obtained by the doctor, without delegation.

None of the three articles gives a deadline. All three, read together, say that the information has a duration and an order: first you understand, then you sign.

What the literature says

A review on information in aesthetic treatments (2018), which reconstructs the case law of the Italian Court of Cassation, writes that the information must be exhaustive, detailed and comprehensible, and that it may be appropriate to give it in writing as well, in order to document that it was given. It reports that the Italian National Bioethics Committee (2012), for aesthetic surgery, asked doctors to verify in detail how much and what the patient has actually taken in.

A text read in the evening, at home, with time for questions, meets that verification better than one read standing at the reception desk. It is not a rule: it is the simplest reading of what the source requires.

Why time weighs when someone challenges you

The same review reports how the Court of Cassation has dealt with failure to inform. For the judges cited, the information is an integral part of the healthcare service, and its absence brings with it professional liability for the violation of the patient's self-determination. Over time the Court has also held that damage is compensable even when consent had not been obtained. This is a reading reported by a review, not a judgment: for the actual decisions you need to look them up by number.

What follows from this for your schedule is practical. If the clinical record shows that the patient received the information days earlier, asked questions and signed when ready, the reconstruction is simple. If it shows that they signed standing up, with the treatment already prepared, the judge has to rely on a signature and nothing else.

Time in practice at the clinic

Recording that the patient had time does not require an internal policy. A simple sequence is enough:

  1. The consultation is separate from the treatment, when the treatment allows it. In the consultation you explain, answer, ask questions. The session comes afterwards.
  2. The written information leaves the clinic: the patient takes it home or reads it on their phone. In the form before the visit you can also write text in addition to the questions, and the clinic sends it by email or SMS a few days earlier.
  3. The consent is signed at the clinic, after the patient has had the chance to ask questions, and with the doctor present.
  4. The clinical record states how much time they had, and whether they decided straight away or came back.

Point 2 needs a careful look. For Fibonacci, signing the consent is a step carried out at the clinic, with the identity document already checked, and sending the consent text before the visit is not currently provided for. The form to be completed before the visit is a different thing: it collects the answers to the questions you have chosen and links them to the right person and the right visit. If you put an information text in it, the patient will read that text beforehand, but it does not replace the consent. Signing from home is not an option today: signing with a code on your phone is coming.

What the patient does at home and what they confirm at the clinic

At home they can read the information, complete the questionnaire, write down the questions that come to them. At the clinic they confirm that they have understood, sign, and decide. The clinic finds the questionnaire linked to the visit, at the top, when it opens it.

The informed consent proper remains a single one: the one signed in front of you, on the text you have re-read. The time discussed here is the time that comes before it.

How to note a refusal or a change of mind

The law says that the patient may refuse the treatment or revoke consent already given, in the same forms as the consent, and that acceptance, revocation and refusal are noted in the clinical record. In practice:

  • If the patient says «I'll think about it», you write: informed on day X, asked for time, will come back later.
  • If they come back, the consent is signed on the day they return, not on the day of the first visit.
  • If they refuse, you write down the refusal, and what you had told them. A documented refusal is as much part of the clinical record as a consent.
  • If they revoke after signing, the original document stays, with the revocation alongside it. In Fibonacci a revoked consent changes status but the archived PDF is not deleted.

A checklist

  • When I gave the information, and to whom
  • What I handed over in writing, and when
  • How much time the patient had to think it over before signing
  • The questions they asked, and my answers
  • How I verified that they had understood
  • Whether they signed the same day or came back
  • Whether they refused, or asked for more time

An example line, with fictional data:

Consultation on 10/06, 45 minutes. Example patient, 38 years old. Treatment, risks, alternatives and timescales explained. Written information sheet handed over. Asked to think it over. Contacted again on 17/06: confirmed, read the information sheet at home, has two questions on recovery times, answers given. Consent signed at the clinic on 20/06, before the session.

There is no right number of days. There is one thing you can demonstrate: that you gave the time to understand before asking for a signature.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The consent catalogue in Fibonacci

Sources

  1. Italian Law 22 December 2017, no. 219, art. 1 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  2. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, artt. 33, 35 and 76 bis (opens in a new tab)
  3. The Central Importance of Information in Cosmetic Surgery and Treatments, 2018, PMC5906625 (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles