Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Ethical marketing for the practice

Before and after photos on social media: when you can publish them and with what consent

Before and after photos on social media: separate written consent, per channel and revocable. What the GDPR, the Garante and advertising rules say.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 7 min read

Someone taking a photo with a phone
In this article
  1. Why the photo in the clinical record and the one on your profile are two different things
  2. What consent to publication must contain
  3. Publishing a photo, and healthcare advertising
  4. When a person recognises themselves
  5. Revocation: how to take it down
  6. What you record in the clinical record

A before and after photo can be published on your website or social media only with the person's explicit consent, given separately from the treatment, for that specific use and that specific channel, and revocable at any time. A verbal agreement is not enough: you must be able to prove that consent exists. On top of that, the published photo must comply with the rules on healthcare advertising, which rule out any attractive or promotional tone.

Why the photo in the clinical record and the one on your profile are two different things

The photo taken during the appointment serves to document the condition of the skin and to make a comparison: it is processing necessary for the treatment, and for that the Garante says that a healthcare professional bound by confidentiality does not ask for consent. How to take it, how to store it and why you need the same framing is in before and after photos in the clinical record.

When the same photo goes on your profile, the purpose changes: it is no longer the treatment, it is making yourself known. The Garante places processing by professionals for commercial purposes among those requiring explicit consent (opens in a new tab). The European regulation requires the same for health data, and a clinical record photo is health data: Article 9, paragraph 2, point (a), permits processing with explicit consent «for one or more specific purposes». Why consent to treatment does not cover publication, and why you do not ask for consent where it is not needed, is explained in to treat, you do not need privacy consent.

Article 7 of the GDPR (opens in a new tab) sets out what is required of consent. Translated for a doctor:

  • You must be able to prove it (paragraph 1). A line in the clinical record saying «patient agrees» is weak evidence: you need a signed or recorded document, with a date.
  • It stands apart (paragraph 2). If it is inside a text that also deals with other matters, the request must be clearly distinguishable, in plain and clear language. It must not be hidden in the treatment form.
  • It is revocable and the patient knows this beforehand (paragraph 3). Revocation must be as easy as giving consent, and before giving it the person is informed that they can do so.
  • It cannot be a condition for treatment (paragraph 4). If the treatment is conditional on consent to processing that is not necessary, the consent risks not being freely given.

The regulation speaks of specific purposes: a generic consent «to the use of my images» describes nothing. It is worth writing:

  • which photos (which shots, which treated area);
  • on which channels (the website, and each social media profile, named);
  • that the photo, in a facial treatment, shows the person and they may be recognisable;
  • that consent can be revoked at any time, and who to write to in order to do so;
  • that saying no does not change the treatment;
  • date, signature and the name of the person who collected the consent.

Publishing a photo, and healthcare advertising

Consent settles the privacy side. The advertising side remains. Italian Law 145/2018 (opens in a new tab), in Article 1, paragraph 525, limits the informational communications of those registered with professional bodies to information functional to correct healthcare information, and rules out «any element of an attractive and suggestive nature», including offers, discounts and promotions. Paragraph 536 gives the Ordine (the professional body) the power to proceed disciplinarily.

The Code of Medical Ethics (opens in a new tab) adds in Article 56 that informational advertising must be «truthful, correct and functional to the subject of the information, never equivocal, misleading or denigrating», and that comparison between treatments is permitted only with measurable and shared clinical indicators. Article 76 bis, for aesthetic medicine, requires not arousing or feeding illusory expectations in the information that precedes consent.

Neither text mentions before and after photos. The criteria apply: is the photo truthful? Is it a case presented as typical when it is the best you have? Does the post accompanying it promise a result, or is there an offer in the caption? A 2025 study on aesthetic medicine notes that on social media before and after photos are often misleading, and that informed consent must include risks and alternatives. Where the texts do not go into detail, a margin of interpretation remains, and the final word belongs to the competent Ordine: see the limits of healthcare advertising.

When a person recognises themselves

The GDPR, in Article 4, point 1, considers a person identifiable if they can be identified «directly or indirectly», with reference to a name, location data, an online identifier or «elements characteristic of their physical identity». For a photo this means the face is not the only thing to look at:

  • a tattoo, a scar, a distinctive mark within the image field;
  • the name in the caption or in the tags;
  • the place and date written in the post;
  • the background: the room, an object, the name of the practice on a coat.

In aesthetic medicine on the face the person is almost always recognisable, because the face is precisely what is being shown. The review on clinical photography reminds us that, when photos are reproduced, the identity must be prevented from emerging: if the person can be seen, the consent must say so clearly. The Code, in Article 11, requires ensuring the non-identifiability of the subjects involved in scientific publications.

Revocation: how to take it down

Article 7, paragraph 3, says that revocation does not affect the lawfulness of what was published before. For the future, however, the photo must be taken down. Article 17 gives the person the right to obtain erasure when they revoke the consent on which the processing is based and there is no other legal ground; and if the data have been made public, the controller must take reasonable measures to inform those processing them of the request to erase links, copies or reproductions (paragraph 2).

To take it down quickly you need to know where it is. Keep a simple register: for each published photo, the date, the channel, the post address and who put it up. If social media are managed by an assistant or an agency, the register applies to them too. A revocation that arrives after two years, without a list, means a manual search across all profiles.

Revocation of consent to publication affects the publication: the clinical photo stays in the clinical record, because its basis is the treatment and not consent.

What you record in the clinical record

The clinical record states what was published and with which consent. A sample line, with fictitious data:

FieldInvented example
PhotoFrontal, before and after, lip area
PurposePromotional (practice website and Instagram profile)
ConsentSigned on 3 March, publication consent form, version 2
PublishedInstagram profile, post of 20 March
RevocationNone

In Fibonacci, when you upload a photo you declare the purpose: clinical, educational or promotional. The clinical one stays in the clinical record; the other two depend on a separate and revocable consent, one for each photo, so in the history you see one per shot and revoking the promotional use of one does not affect the others. If consent is missing, the photo remains clinical and does not leave the clinical record. The pages on photos and comparison and on consents describe the steps, and the guide to before and after photos summarises everything in a few lines. For measures on images, there is the page on legal protection for photographs and privacy.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

Sessions with product and batch in Fibonacci, with sample data

Sources

  1. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali (Italian Data Protection Authority), clarifications on the processing of health data, 7 March 2019 [9091942] (opens in a new tab)
  2. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Articles 7, 9, 17 (EUR-Lex) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 4, point 1: personal data and identifiable person (EUR-Lex) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Italian Law 30 December 2018, no. 145, Article 1, paragraphs 525 and 536 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  5. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, Articles 11, 56 and 76 bis (opens in a new tab)
  6. Clinical photography for periorbital and facial aesthetic practice, 2016, PMC4924408 (opens in a new tab)
  7. Are we in an ethical dilemma in aesthetic medicine?, 2025, PMC12136130 (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles