No: to treat a patient you do not have to ask for their consent to the processing of their data. That is what the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali (the Italian data protection authority) wrote in its provision of 7 March 2019: a healthcare professional bound by professional secrecy no longer has to request consent for the processing necessary for the service the patient has asked for. The «privacy consent» form that many practices have patients sign at the first appointment, for consultations and treatments, is not required. Other things remain mandatory: the privacy notice, the informed consent to treatment, and a separate consent for anything that has nothing to do with the treatment.
Three different things, often on a single form
First-appointment paperwork usually mixes up three documents that have different legal bases, functions and consequences.
- The privacy notice. This is the text in which you tell the patient who processes their data, for what, on what legal basis, for how long, to whom you communicate it, and what rights they have. You give it, you do not ask for it.
- Consent to the processing of data. This is the patient's authorisation for you to process their data. For care, it is not needed. It is needed for other processing, the kind that care does not make necessary.
- Informed consent to treatment. This is something else again: it concerns the medical treatment, not the data. It is required by law and does not merge with the two above.
The reason they get confused is historical: in the provision we look at below, the Garante writes «unlike in the past», and many forms have stayed as they were before.
What the Garante says
The GDPR generally prohibits the processing of data concerning health (Article 9(1)) and then lists the exceptions. Two matter for your practice:
- the data subject's explicit consent for specific purposes (paragraph 2(a));
- processing necessary for the purposes of preventive medicine, diagnosis, the provision of health care or treatment, on the basis of Union or Member State law or a contract with a health professional (paragraph 2(h)), provided the data are processed by or under the responsibility of a professional subject to professional secrecy or another person bound by secrecy (paragraph 3).
In the 2019 provision the Garante calls this second case «care purposes» and draws the consequence: unlike in the past, a healthcare professional bound by secrecy does not have to ask for consent for the processing necessary for the requested service, and it does not matter whether they work in a sole-trader practice or within a public or private facility.
Two clarifications from the same provision, which are the ones that often get lost:
«Necessary» means necessary. Paragraph 2(h) covers processing essential to achieving purposes related to the protection of health. Processing that concerns care only in a broad sense, but is not strictly necessary, requires a separate legal basis: the data subject's consent or another ground for lawfulness, even if it is carried out by a healthcare professional.
The list of cases where explicit consent is needed. The Garante gives some by way of example, including:
- medical applications through which an autonomous controller collects health data, where persons other than healthcare professionals can access them;
- processing for promotional or commercial purposes carried out by private parties in the healthcare field;
- processing carried out by healthcare professionals for commercial or electoral purposes;
- the electronic health record, for which consent is required by sector-specific rules;
- online delivery of reports, where consent concerns the manner in which the report is delivered.
The list is illustrative, not exhaustive: each item must be assessed against the specific processing you carry out.
Consent is needed for other things
For an aesthetic medicine practice this means that consent to the processing of data is requested separately for anything that goes beyond care:
- Photos used for purposes other than care. A clinical photo taken to document the treatment is part of the record and does not require privacy consent. The same photo for a conference, for social media or for the website is different processing, with a different purpose.
- Promotional messages, newsletters, offers. These are commercial purposes. Bear in mind that healthcare communication is also subject to a specific rule (Italian Law 145/2018), which we discuss in what a doctor may write on their website and on social media.
- Online delivery of reports, in accordance with the Garante's rules set out above.
- Digital services accessible to persons who are not healthcare professionals. The example the Garante gives is medical applications.
When consent is requested, the GDPR says how. The controller must be able to demonstrate it (Article 7(1)). If consent appears in a text that also covers other matters, the request must be «clearly distinguishable from the other matters», in clear and plain language (paragraph 2). And the patient may withdraw it at any time, as easily as they gave it (paragraph 3).
This last point explains why the single form does harm. If treatment, privacy and promotion all sit under the same signature, the patient cannot withdraw the promotional part without calling everything else into question.
What the privacy notice must say
Article 13 of the GDPR lists what the controller communicates when collecting data from the patient. In summary:
| Item | What to write |
|---|---|
| Controller | Who you are, with contact details |
| Data protection officer | Contact, if you have one |
| Purposes and legal basis | For example: care, under Art. 9(2)(h) and (3) |
| Recipients | Who receives the data (labs, accountant for what they need, suppliers) |
| Transfers outside the EU | If any, with the safeguards |
| Retention | For how long, or by what criteria |
| Rights | Access, rectification, erasure, restriction, objection, portability |
| Withdrawal of consent | If you process anything on the basis of consent: the right to withdraw it |
| Complaint | The right to lodge a complaint with the supervisory authority |
In the same provision the Garante recalls that the information must be provided in a concise, transparent, intelligible and easily accessible form, in clear and plain language, and that the controller chooses the most appropriate manner based on the context. A notice you can read in ten lines and re-read at home is worth more than a four-page one in six-point type. In the texts I have read, you are required to provide it, not to have it signed: if you want to keep a record of delivery, that is your own organisational choice, not an obligation arising from these texts.
Informed consent remains, and it is a separate document
Italian Law 219/2017 (opens in a new tab) (Article 1) states that no medical treatment may be started without free and informed consent, and that it must be documented and placed in the record. It has nothing to do with privacy: it concerns what you will do to the patient, not what you will do with their data. A «privacy consent» does not replace it, and it is not replaced by one. How to do it properly is covered in informed consent in aesthetic medicine.
A first-appointment pack in order
A realistic arrangement for the practice, in three separate documents plus the optional ones:
| Document | Signed? | When |
|---|---|---|
| Privacy notice | Given; signature is not required by the texts read | At the first visit, and when it changes |
| Informed consent to treatment | Yes | Before each treatment, one per treatment |
| Consent to photos for non-clinical purposes | Yes, separately, revocable | Only if you want to use the photos outside care |
| Consent to promotional communications | Yes, separately, revocable | Only if you intend to send them |
What follows from this table: a form called «consent to the processing of personal data» that the patient signs in order to be seen no longer has a function for care. If you remove it, you lose nothing for that purpose. If you keep it, you risk making the patient (and yourself) believe that your legal basis is consent, with the consequence that they can withdraw it.
The check to carry out once, on your current form:
- Is there a «privacy consent» form needed in order to be seen? It should be removed or turned into a notice
- Does the notice contain all the items in the Article 13 table?
- Is the informed consent specific to each treatment, separate from the notice?
- Do photos for non-clinical purposes and promotional messages have a separate, revocable consent?
- Can you demonstrate when and how each consent was given?
How Fibonacci organises it
For photos, the record provides that, on upload, the purpose must be declared: clinical, teaching or promotional. The clinical one always stays in the record and does not require privacy consent, in line with the Garante's guidance. The other two depend on a separate, revocable consent, and each photo carries its own: withdrawing the promotional use of one photo does not affect the others. Italian Law 145/2018 applies to promotion. See the clinical photos and comparison feature and the before and after photos guide.
For communications, the patient record has a field for consent to communications, and the email appointment reminder is sent only if the patient has consented to that channel. No promotional message goes out on its own.
For informed consent, the templates and the procedure are explained in informed consents and on the legal protection: generic consent page.
Fibonacci does not write your privacy notice and does not decide your legal basis. Those are choices for the controller, that is, the practice. For a review of an individual practice, you need your privacy consultant or your data protection officer, if you have one.




