Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Practice regulations

How long is a medical record kept and where

Medical record retention in a medical practice: the GDPR criterion, prescription periods as the horizon, what to do with consents and photos, and how to delete them.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 9 min read

Coloured ring binders on office shelves
In this article
  1. The GDPR criterion
  2. How long you can be called to answer
  3. What the rules on records say
  4. What you keep, for how long, and on what ground
  5. Paper and digital: where
  6. Archiving and deleting: how it is recorded
  7. When you change practice management software
  8. A rule written in half an hour

How long you keep a record is decided by a criterion, not by a number learned by heart: as long as you can be called to answer for your work, and no longer than is needed for the purposes for which you keep it. The first point is measured by limitation periods, the second by the GDPR principle of storage limitation. The period, or the criterion for determining it, must be set out in the information given to patients.

A record deleted too early takes away the evidence with which to defend yourself. One kept without a reason is health data held longer than necessary. Both are mistakes, and for both a rule written once is enough.

The GDPR criterion

Article 5(1)(e) requires that data be kept in a form which permits identification of the persons for no longer than is necessary for the purposes for which they are processed ("storage limitation"). It does not say how many years: it says that a reason is needed, and that once the reason ends the data do not stay.

The same regulation requires the duration to be communicated. Article 13(2)(a) requires the information to state the period for which the data will be stored or, if that is not possible, the criteria used to determine that period. So a sentence such as "we keep clinical documentation for as long as the practice can be called to answer for its work" is already a criterion, whereas a field left blank is not.

At the other end, the patient may request erasure (Article 17), and the regulation provides for it, among other things, where the data are no longer necessary for the purposes. But paragraph 3 of the same article excludes erasure where processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation (point b), for reasons of public interest in the area of public health (point c), and for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims (point e). The answer to an erasure request is therefore not automatic and is not a blanket refusal: it is an assessment, reasoned, and written down. For data that are not clinical (a contact detail, an administrative note) the picture changes, and those are deleted.

How long you can be called to answer

The criterion "as long as it serves to defend you" has a horizon, and limitation periods provide it.

  • The ordinary period is ten years (Article 2946 of the Italian Civil Code), unless the law provides otherwise.
  • The right to compensation for damage from a wrongful act is time-barred five years from the day on which the act occurred (Article 2947). If the act is regarded by law as a criminal offence and a longer limitation period is laid down for the offence, that period also applies to the civil action.
  • Limitation begins to run from the day on which the right can be enforced (Article 2935).

Which of the two regimes applies depends on the relationship. Italian Law 24/2017 (opens in a new tab), Article 7(3), states that a healthcare professional answers for their work under Article 2043 of the Italian Civil Code (liability in tort), unless they acted in performance of a contractual obligation assumed with the patient. The healthcare facility, by contrast, answers under Articles 1218 and 1228 of the Italian Civil Code (Article 7(1)). A doctor in private practice, with a patient who has instructed them directly, may fall within the contractual exception. Which one applies to you is for your lawyer to decide, but the practical horizon is this: the periods range from five to ten years, and may run from a moment other than the date of treatment. That is why counting from the last visit is prudent but is not enough as a rule.

What the rules on records say

The code of medical ethics (opens in a new tab) does not give a number of years, but governs how a record is kept:

  • Article 26 requires completeness, clarity and diligence, confidentiality, reasoned and signed corrections, traceability of authorship, and that the manner and timing of the information and the terms of consent or refusal be recorded;
  • Article 25 requires clinical documentation to be made available to the patient, their legal representative or the doctors and institutions they have designated in writing;
  • Italian Law 219/2017 (opens in a new tab) (Article 1(4)) requires that informed consent, in whatever form it is expressed, be entered in the record;
  • Article 78, in its application guidance, requires reliable systems and formats independent of the platform, with availability, confidentiality and storage arrangements assured.

Italian Law 24/2017, Article 4(2), provides that the medical management of a public or private facility must supply the available health documentation within seven days of a request by those entitled to it, with additions within thirty days. That is a rule for facilities; for the copy given to the patient see the copy of the clinical record.

The Garante, in its decision of 10 July 2025, fined a medical centre 30,000 euros for failing to respond within the time limit to a request for access to and a copy of the record: Article 12(3) of the GDPR gives one month from receipt, extendable by two in complex cases.

What you keep, for how long, and on what ground

One way to do this is a table to fill in with your adviser. You choose the periods on the basis of the criterion above; here you have the grounds.

WhatWhy it is keptUntil when
Clinical record: history, treatments, outcomesCare and defence in legal proceedingsThe end of the limitation horizon you have chosen
Signed informed consent formsThey prove that consent was given, and under Italian Law 219/2017 they must be entered in the recordAs long as the record to which they relate
Withdrawn consentProof that consent was in place when the treatment was carried outAs long as the record: withdrawal does not erase it
Clinical photographsThey form part of the recordAs long as the record
Photographs for purposes other than care (website, social media)A different purpose, with its own legal basis: if that is consent, the patient can withdraw itUntil withdrawal or the end of the use
Access logsTo show who opened whatFor dossier cases the Garante requires at least 24 months (the cases are here); in Fibonacci they are kept as long as the clinical documentation
Audio recordings of a video callOnly if the patient has consentedUntil a short, stated expiry date

Paper and digital: where

The GDPR also applies to non-automated processing of data contained in a filing system (Article 2(1)), so a paper record is a filing system of health data just like a digital one. Article 32 requires measures appropriate to the risk: who has the key to the cabinet, where it is, what happens if the practice is flooded.

For digital records, the question is where the data are and who touches them: you will find it in where the patient's data are. The minimum you need to know: locations, backups (encrypted, with proof of restoration), and who can open what.

Archiving and deleting: how it is recorded

Deletion is an act that is written down. What the log needs is:

  • the date of the decision and who took it;
  • what was deleted, for what reason and under which retention criterion;
  • what was kept and why (for example, in the case of an erasure request, the reasons why the clinical documentation remains);
  • how you replied to the patient, if there was a request.

In Fibonacci deletion is not automatic and does not start by itself at a patient's request: it must be assessed, and the assessment is written down. The access log remains even after a patient has been deleted, without their name but with the trace that the operation took place, because a log that disappears along with the data would no longer prove anything. For audio recordings of a video call there is a 30-day expiry from saving: once it has passed, the row says "To be deleted" and you delete it with a confirmation.

When you change practice management software

The moment when retention most often breaks down is when you leave a program. The order matters: you export everything, you check that you have received the package, and only then do you delete. Reversing it means destroying the only readable copy.

The GDPR provides the tools: portability in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format (Article 20), and for the processor the obligation to return or delete the data at the end of the service, at the controller's choice (Article 28(3)(g)). In Fibonacci the clinical record is exported in three forms from the patient file menu: PDF, CSV and FHIR. The PDF contains personal details, history, treatments, prescriptions, tests, consents and the access history, and is the copy to hand over for a data access request. The FHIR file is a ZIP with the data in the FHIR R4 standard, the photographs, the reports and a file with the SHA-256 fingerprint of each file. The photographs, encrypted in storage, are decrypted at the moment of export so that whoever receives them can open them. The package does not contain the encryption key, which would open every existing encrypted copy, including those in the backups; once delivery is confirmed, the key for that project is destroyed, and with it the remaining backups are no longer readable by anyone.

One mistake to avoid: sending photographs by ordinary messaging. They are health data.

A rule written in half an hour

  • The information notice states the retention period, or the criterion for determining it
  • I have chosen a horizon for the clinical documentation, and the reason (limitation periods) is written down
  • Consents, clinical photographs and the record follow the same horizon; promotional photographs have their own duration
  • Who decides on a deletion, and where they record it, is clear
  • I know what to reply to a patient who asks for the deletion of clinical data, and I write it down
  • For every archive (cabinet, practice management software, phone) I know who can open it
  • If I change practice management software: first I export and check, then I delete

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The patient record in Fibonacci, with sample data

Sources

  1. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Articles 2, 5, 13, 17, 20, 28 and 32 (opens in a new tab)
  2. Italian Law 8 March 2017, No. 24 (Gelli-Bianco), Articles 4 and 7 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Italian Law 22 December 2017, No. 219, Article 1, paragraph 4: informed consent filed in the medical record (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Italian Civil Code, Articles 2935, 2946 and 2947: start date and limitation periods (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  5. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics (2014, with updates to Articles 54, 56, 76 and 77), Articles 25 and 26 and Article 78 (opens in a new tab)
  6. Garante privacy, measure of 10 July 2025, No. 450 [doc. web 10168519]: medical record and right of access (fine) (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles