Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Ethical marketing for the practice

How to respond to a negative review without breaching professional confidentiality

Answering a negative review as a doctor: never confirm the author is a patient, what you can and cannot say, and how to ask for reviews.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 7 min read

Row of yellow stars on a pink and blue background
In this article
  1. What the texts say
  2. Replying without confirming
  3. A template reply, without health data
  4. Reports and legal avenues
  5. Asking for reviews without forcing
  6. How Fibonacci behaves

A negative review is answered without confirming that the person who wrote it is your patient, and without saying anything of what you know about him or her: not the treatment, not the date, not the outcome, not the price. Even if the person has written "I came to see you", the reply remains the one you would give to anyone. It is professional secrecy: everything you know by reason of your activity, including the fact that someone came to you.

What the texts say

The Code of Medical Ethics. Article 10 (opens in a new tab) rests on two points that matter here. Secrecy covers "everything of which he is aware" by reason of the activity, not only the diagnosis. And the breach is more serious when own or another's profit may derive from it, or harm to the person assisted: a public reply that serves to defend your reputation risks falling within this reading. Article 11 requires the doctor to respect confidentiality, in particular of data concerning health.

The criminal code. Article 622 (opens in a new tab) punishes anyone who, having knowledge of a secret by reason of his own profession, discloses it without just cause, if harm may derive from the act: with imprisonment for up to one year or with a fine. The offence is punishable on complaint of the offended person.

The GDPR. "Data concerning health" include, under Article 4, point 15 (opens in a new tab), also those on the provision of health care services which reveal information about the state of health. Saying in public that a person came to you for a certain treatment is data of this kind.

That the person has written that he or she was your patient is not a just cause written in the texts. Whether in a specific case a review allows you to reply on the merits, none of the texts cited says: it is a point to bring to a lawyer or to the Ordine before writing, not to decide in public.

Replying without confirming

The criterion is not to give information that the person has not already given, and not to give different information depending on whether or not he or she is a patient. If you reply in one way to someone who came to you and in another to someone who never came, the difference is enough to reveal who is who. For this reason it is worth having a single reply, valid for everyone.

What can be said in general:

  • a thank you to the person who wrote and regret for the experience described, without going into the merits;
  • that for professional confidentiality individual relationships with the persons assisted are neither confirmed nor commented on, even when they are the ones speaking about them;
  • how the patient can contact you privately (telephone, practice address), where you can listen and reply;
  • if you wish, a sentence on how you work in general, within the limits of prudent and accessible information (art. 55) and without promotion.

What is never written:

  • that the person is or was your patient ("I remember his session well", "as he told us at the visit");
  • the treatment, the area, the date, the number of sessions, the product;
  • the outcome, the complications, the clinical history, what he told you or did not tell you;
  • the price paid, the invoices, the details of a payment;
  • a photo, a reference to the record, a comparison with other patients;
  • an attack on the person or a denigrating tone.

On this last point, article 56 of the Code is written for informative advertising, but its criteria (truthful, correct, never equivocal, misleading and denigrating) are a good yardstick for any public text that goes out with your name. An irritated reply is read by those who are deciding whether to come to you.

A template reply, without health data

A text to adapt to your tone. It does not say whether the person writing is or is not a patient, and it works for any review:

"Good morning, thank you for writing and we are sorry for what you describe. For professional confidentiality we can neither confirm nor comment on individual relationships with the persons we assist, even when they are the ones speaking about them. If you wish to explain to us what did not work, you can contact us at the number shown in the listing, where we will listen to you with due confidentiality."

Adapt it to your tone without adding sentences that say anything about the person.

If the review is false, offensive, or refers to a person who never came to you, there are two routes, and they are not mutually exclusive. The first is reporting to the platform, with the tools the platform offers. The second is assessment with a lawyer: which routes exist, whether it is worth it, with what evidence. In neither case do you write in public "this person was never my patient": you verify the fact in the record, and you communicate it to the platform or to the lawyer, not to readers. Even denying is information about the relationship, and the single reply protects you here too.

For doubts of deontology on your communications the venue is the Ordine, which is responsible for verification (art. 56). Keep a copy, with the date, of the review and of your reply.

Asking for reviews without forcing

Italian Law 145/2018, in article 1, paragraph 525, limits the communications of those registered with professional bodies to information functional to correct health information and excludes "any element of an attractive and suggestive character", including offers, discounts and promotions. Paragraph 536 gives the Ordine disciplinary power. None of the texts names reviews, and the criteria apply. Three prudent rules follow:

  • Nothing in return. A discount, a free gift, a package for those who write a review is the offer that the paragraph names. The texts do not name it, but it resembles what the paragraph excludes: in doubt, ask the Ordine.
  • No suggested text, no five stars. Those who write describe their own experience: a message that dictates the words or the rating to them produces reviews that are not truthful.
  • Ask as you would ask a favour, not as a campaign. The Garante, in its clarifications of 7 March 2019, lists among the health treatments requiring explicit consent (opens in a new tab) those of professionals for commercial purposes. A message asking for a review serves to make you known, it is closer to promotion than to care. Before sending it to all patients, ask a privacy consultant whether and to whom you may write it. Care is not the legal basis of such a message: the difference is explained in per curare non serve il consenso privacy.

How Fibonacci behaves

Fibonacci does not collect reviews and does not publish rankings of doctors. The public listing of each practice, reachable without credentials, shows where you are, what you do, opening hours and contact details, and does not host reviews (prenotazione online). The choice has a reason that concerns professional secrecy itself: to verify a review it would be necessary to link the person writing to his or her clinical record, that is, to declare that that person was a patient of that doctor. It is the same problem as your public reply, and the software does not solve it, it avoids it by not collecting them.

For the general framework there is the page on pubblicità del medico, and for the listing on the map the article on the scheda Google dello studio. The limits of website and social media are in pubblicità sanitaria su sito e social.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The practice schedule in Fibonacci, with sample data

Sources

  1. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, Articles 10 (professional secrecy), 11 (confidentiality of personal data) and 56 (opens in a new tab)
  2. Italian Criminal Code, Article 622: disclosure of professional secrecy (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 4, point 15: data concerning health (EUR-Lex) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali), clarifications on the processing of health data, 7 March 2019 [9091942] (opens in a new tab)
  5. Italian Law 30 December 2018, No. 145, Article 1, paragraphs 525 and 536 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles