A reminder recalls an appointment that has already been booked. A recall brings back to the practice a patient who does not have an appointment. They are two tools with different risks: the first is a courtesy with a time inside it, the second is an invitation, and an invitation that insists becomes pressure. In Fibonacci the recall originates as an internal practice activity, with a due date and a person responsible for it, and no message goes out to the patient on its own.
The decisions to be made are these: what distinguishes a recall from a reminder, who decides the timing, what to write in the message, what to ask the patient and what not to do. The technical part is on the reminders page.
Reminders and recalls, two different things
| Reminder | Recall | |
|---|---|---|
| When | The day before an appointment | After a treatment, on a chosen date |
| To whom | To the patient with a booked appointment | To a patient who has no appointment |
| What it says | The time and how to cancel | That the practice is available |
| In Fibonacci | Automatic email, if switched on and if consent to the channel exists | Internal activity, to be done by hand |
| Risk | Revealing health data in the text | Looking like a promotion |
We discuss reminders in the article on how to reduce missed appointments: it goes out at 9 for the next day's appointments, only if the patient has given consent to the email channel, and without stating the reason for the visit. The rest of these pages concerns recalls.
Who decides the timing of the recall
The person who writes the consent decides, that is, you. Fibonacci does not estimate when a patient should return. When you save a session whose product has an expected duration written in the consent, the program proposes a recall on the right date. If the duration is not there, it proposes nothing: an invented recall looks like the doctor's advice, and it is not.
Two choices are declared, and they are worth knowing:
- The recall is set at the lower end of the duration. If the consent says "from 4 to 6 months" (example), the recall falls at 4: a patient contacted again when the effect has already worn off has gone elsewhere in the meantime.
- Each entry says where it comes from, quoting the sentence in the consent. A reminder that cannot say why it is there is a reminder the doctor switches off.
If you save the same session twice you do not get two recalls, and beyond the maximum expected duration the recall disappears from the list of things to do today: the right moment has passed, and showing it as urgent would be noise.
Recalls sit in the Activities section, together with the other things to do in the practice, and are managed like the others: you assign them to a person, they have a due date, a comment, a status (To do, In progress, Waiting, Done). Book an appointment opens the diary with the patient already selected. Activities between doctors are not seen by the receptionist, because they may discuss clinical matters: she sees one only if a doctor assigns it to her. For a recall to be done by phone, assign it to her.
What to write in the message
The rule is the same as for reminders: no health data in the text. The GDPR, in Article 9 (opens in a new tab), generally prohibits the processing of data concerning health, save for the exceptions it lists. An SMS or an email arrives on a phone that may be in someone else's hand, and saying "your treatment for X" says something about someone's health.
Two examples of text, with fictional data:
| Text | Why |
|---|---|
| "Good morning, you are being contacted by Dr Rossi's practice. Could you call us back when it suits you? Telephone 000 0000000." | It says who is writing and how to reply, and nothing else |
| "Good morning, the time since your last filler treatment has passed: book your top-up now with 15% off." | It names the treatment and contains a promotion: two mistakes in one line |
The program reasons this way elsewhere too: the text it prepares for contacting patients after a batch recall does not state the reason for the contact. The reason is given by voice.
Consent to contact and the right to opt out
Article 130 (opens in a new tab) deals with unwanted communications. In paragraphs 1 and 2 it permits the sending of advertising material, direct sales or commercial communication by automated means, email, SMS and MMS only with the recipient's consent. Paragraph 4 allows you not to ask for it, in order to sell services similar to those already purchased, if you use the email address left by the data subject on that occasion, if the data subject is informed and does not refuse, and on condition that they are reminded, on every sending, that they may object at any time, easily and free of charge. Paragraph 5 prohibits in any case sending these messages while concealing the sender's identity or without a contact point for exercising one's rights.
The question that remains open is whether a recall is a commercial communication. A message proposing a check-up after a treatment is close to care. A message inviting the patient to redo the treatment is close to selling. The boundary is not drawn once and for all, and on a specific case it is worth asking your privacy consultant to confirm. The prudent approach is simple:
- record the channel choice in the patient's record (email, telephone, none);
- always write who you are and how to reply;
- a patient who says "do not call me again" comes off the list, and you write that down;
- if the message has a sales feel, treat it as such and ask for consent.
For mass messages, such as newsletters, see the article on the patient newsletter.
What not to do
Italian Law 145/2018 (opens in a new tab), in Article 1, paragraph 525, excludes from health information communications any attractive and suggestive element, including communications with offers, discounts and promotions. Paragraph 536 says that professional bodies proceed disciplinarily and report breaches to the Communications Regulatory Authority. The responsibility lies with the doctor, not the program.
For a recall this means:
- no discounts or offers for those who return;
- no deadlines ("by Friday") or pressure;
- no phrases that make the patient feel at fault if they do not reply;
- no recalls to patients who have already said no.
The program, by choice, sends nothing automatically. When you decide to write, you do it yourself, from your own channel.
How to see how many respond
Fibonacci does not measure how many people respond to a recall, because the recall does not go through the program. There are, however, two useful numbers, both imprecise:
- in the
Activitiessection, theOverduefilter says how many recalls you have let lapse, andDonehow many you have closed in the last thirty days; - in the statistics, the returning patients for the period (a patient is new if before the period they had no attended appointment).
The second number does not say whether a patient returned because of a recall or of their own accord. To know that, write the outcome of the phone call in the activity comment: one line is enough.
Before setting up recalls: a checklist
- The expected duration of each treatment is written in the consent
- I have decided who calls, and the recall is assigned to that person
- The text does not name treatments and contains no discounts
- The text says who is writing and how to reply
- The channel choice is recorded in the record
- Those who say no come off the list, and that is written down
- Every month I look at overdue recalls




