Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Ethical marketing for the practice

The practice newsletter to patients: what you can send and what consent is needed

A practice newsletter to patients: it needs its own consent, separate from treatment consent (art. 130 of the Privacy Code). What to write and how.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 7 min read

White envelope on a black background
In this article
  1. What counts as a commercial communication
  2. Consent: separate from consent to treatment
  3. The address taken at a visit is not good for everything
  4. How it is collected and how it is documented
  5. What a medical practice newsletter contains
  6. Health data in the message: none
  7. Unsubscribing and objecting
  8. Where Fibonacci stands

To send a promotional newsletter to patients by email you need their consent, before sending it. Consent must be specific to that purpose, separate from consent to treatment (which is not needed in order to treat), and you must be able to demonstrate when and from whom you received it. There is one exception, written for email, and it concerns services analogous to those already provided.

What counts as a commercial communication

Article 130 of the Italian Privacy Code (opens in a new tab) refers to sending advertising material, direct selling, market research and commercial communication. Paragraph 2 applies it to email, SMS and MMS. A newsletter that presents a treatment, reminds patients that «you can book» or announces a novelty at the practice to bring patients in falls under this. A reminder of an appointment already booked is another matter: it promotes nothing.

Italian Legislative Decree 70/2003 (opens in a new tab) adds three things for commercial communications online. From the very first send they must state that they are commercial communications and on whose behalf they are sent (art. 8). Unsolicited emails must be identifiable as such from the moment they arrive and must indicate that the recipient can object to further ones, and the burden of proving that they were solicited lies with the sender (art. 9). Those practising a regulated profession use them in compliance with professional ethics: independence, dignity, honour of the profession, professional secrecy, fairness towards clients and colleagues (art. 10).

The Garante, in its decision of 7 March 2019, clarified that healthcare professionals no longer ask for consent for processing necessary for treatment, and included among the processing operations that do require it those «for commercial purposes» by healthcare professionals. It follows that the form with which the patient accepts your privacy notice cannot also contain the opt-in to the newsletter. The reason is Article 7 of the GDPR (opens in a new tab): if consent is given in a declaration that also concerns other matters, the request must be presented in a clearly distinguishable manner; it can be withdrawn at any time, as easily as it was given; and in assessing whether it is freely given, account is taken of the fact that the service is conditional on consent that is not necessary. Treating a patient cannot depend on subscribing to the newsletter. For the full reasoning there is the article on privacy consent that is not needed in order to treat.

The Garante's guidelines on spam (opens in a new tab) (from 2013, predating the GDPR) set out what promotional consent must be like: freely given, informed, specific, documented. A pre-ticked box is not correct. Consent made conditional on the use of a service is not freely given. And to prove it you must document the date on which it was given and the details of the person who received it, with a procedure that ensures withdrawal is respected.

The address taken at a visit is not good for everything

The email the patient leaves you at reception was given for another reason: to contact them about the appointment, to send them a document. Using it for a newsletter is another purpose, and requires their consent.

The exception is paragraph 4 of Article 130, the one called «soft spam». If you use the email details that the data subject provided to you in the context of the sale of a product or service, for the direct selling of your own products or services, you may not need to ask for consent, provided that the services are analogous to those that were the subject of the sale and the data subject, duly informed, does not refuse. The data subject must be informed of the possibility of objecting, easily and free of charge, at the time of collection and in every message. The 2013 guidelines specify that the exception applies to email only; the 2026 decision allows it «solely» where the email address, and only that, was provided in the context of a sale of analogous goods or services. It does not apply to SMS, and it does not apply to other patient data. If your case does not clearly fall within it (a newsletter about treatments other than the one already performed, an address taken for something else entirely), the safe route is to ask for consent.

How it is collected and how it is documented

Consent is requested with a single, separate question, and without ticking it on the patient's behalf. In practice, a dedicated box on the form, on the tablet or in the online form works, with the text of what will be received and how often. What matters is being able to reconstruct every opt-in. An example of a register row, with fictitious data:

DataExample
Addresspaziente.esempio@example.com (opens in a new tab)
Consent given on9 March 2026
Howdedicated box on the tablet, at the practice
Text shownversion 2 («practice news by email, roughly once a month»)
Collected byreception
Withdrawn on(empty)

The date and who collected the opt-in are the elements the guidelines require you to document. The text and the version serve to know what the patient said yes to.

What a medical practice newsletter contains

The same rule applies as for other healthcare communications: Italian Law 145/2018 (opens in a new tab) (art. 1, paragraph 525) permits only information functional to correct health information and excludes any attractive or suggestive element, including offers, discounts and promotions. A practice newsletter, then, informs: opening hours and closures, a treatment described with its characteristics and its limits, a change in the law that concerns patients, the fee for a procedure. It does not contain a «this week only», nor the result of a selected case presented as typical. The part on tone and on the criteria for assessment is in the article on healthcare advertising.

Health data in the message: none

The GDPR treats as data concerning health also data relating to the provision of healthcare services that reveal information about health status (art. 4, point 15), and prohibits processing them save for the exceptions in art. 9. For a newsletter the consequence is practical: no recipient must be able to see the other addresses, because the list would reveal who is a patient of the practice; and the text must not name the treatment performed on an individual person («it has been a year since your filler»). The message speaks to everyone in the same way.

Unsubscribing and objecting

The patient can object to direct marketing at any time, and from that moment the data are no longer processed for that purpose (GDPR art. 21, paragraphs 2 and 3). The right must be brought to the data subject's attention clearly and separately from the rest, at the latest at the first communication (paragraph 4). So at the bottom of every message an unsubscribe link, easily and free of charge (art. 130, paragraph 4), and a contact point to write to (paragraph 5). Anyone who unsubscribes is entered in the register as withdrawn, with the date, and receives nothing further: you must be able to demonstrate consent (GDPR art. 7(1)), and the guidelines require procedures that ensure withdrawal is respected.

Where Fibonacci stands

The newsletter is among the features to come: today it does not exist. What does exist, and must not be confused with it, are the practice's reminders: recalls that originate from a session and remain an internal activity, for the doctor, with no automatic message to the patient. The appointment reminder by email, where it is switched on, is sent only if the patient's record contains consent to the email channel, does not name the reason for the visit and carries a link to cancel. These are two different things from a newsletter, and consent to the channel does not turn into consent to marketing.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The practice schedule in Fibonacci, with sample data

Sources

  1. Italian Legislative Decree 30 June 2003, no. 196 (Privacy Code), art. 130, unsolicited communications (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Italian Legislative Decree 9 April 2003, no. 70, arts. 8, 9 and 10, e-commerce (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), arts. 4, 7, 9 and 21 (EUR-Lex) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Garante privacy, clarifications on health data, 7 March 2019 [9091942] (opens in a new tab)
  5. Garante privacy, guidelines on promotional activities and combating spam, 4 July 2013 [2542348] (opens in a new tab)
  6. Garante privacy, provision 14 May 2026 [10262105], commercial communications by email (opens in a new tab)
  7. Italian Law 30 December 2018, no. 145, art. 1, paragraph 525 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles