Skip to content
FibonacciAestheticsLog inTry it free

Consent and legal protection

Who can do what in an aesthetic clinic: what cannot be delegated and what the rules leave open

Who can perform injections, lasers and peels: diagnosis, prescription and consent cannot be delegated. What the Code, Law 24/2017 and EU rules say.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 6 min read

University degree certificate with signatures and a seal
In this article
  1. What cannot be delegated
  2. What the rules leave open
  3. The two limits that are written down
  4. Responsibility
  5. What to write in the record when one part is carried out by others
  6. A user with limited permissions

Three acts belong to the doctor and cannot be delegated: diagnosis, prescription and obtaining consent. For the rest of a treatment (who prepares, who assists, who carries out one part) the rules do not give you a table. They refer back to national rules on qualifications, and they set two boundaries: having an act reserved to someone who is not authorised carried out is a criminal offence, and responsibility for what happens in the practice is not divided by internal paperwork.

If you have an assistant, a nurse, someone on reception, you wonder where the boundary lies. What a nurse may do in your region is set by sector-specific rules; here you have the general rules and what to write in the record so that the boundary is visible.

What cannot be delegated

The Code of Medical Ethics (opens in a new tab) is clear on three acts.

  • Diagnosis. Article 3: for preventive, therapeutic and rehabilitative purposes, it is the «direct, exclusive and non-delegable» competence of the doctor.
  • Prescription. Article 13: it is direct, specific, exclusive and non-delegable competence, and must follow a detailed diagnosis or a well-founded diagnostic suspicion.
  • Consent. Article 35: obtaining it is an act of specific and exclusive competence of the doctor, non-delegable.

For an aesthetic practice this means concrete things. The consultation in which you decide what to do is yours. Reception books and welcomes, but does not diagnose or prescribe. And consent is not obtained by having reception hand over a sheet and a pen: the doctor obtains it, after informing the patient.

What the rules leave open

Article 66 of the Code asks the doctor to foster collaboration and integration among the health professionals involved in care, «with respect for each other's competences, autonomy and related responsibilities», and for reserved activities. It does not list who may perform which act. It refers back to the competences defined by other rules.

European Regulation 2022/2346 (opens in a new tab) uses the same technique. For the fillers in Annex IV, the label must state that the product is «to be administered exclusively by health professionals adequately trained, qualified or accredited in accordance with national law». For the lipolysis and liposuction equipment in Annex V, the instructions state that invasive devices must be used in an adequate medical environment by doctors trained and qualified in accordance with national law, and that the doctor must be assisted by at least one other doctor or another qualified health professional. In neither case does the European regulation say which profession is authorised: it says that the answer lies in national law.

What falls within that national law, for a single technique and a single professional figure (nurses, aestheticians, other professions), is established by sector-specific rules and by the regions: that is a question to put to your lawyer or to the Order before organising the practice.

The two limits that are written down

The criminal offence. Article 348 of the Italian Criminal Code (opens in a new tab) punishes anyone who unlawfully practises a profession for which a special State authorisation is required, with imprisonment from six months to three years and a fine from 10,000 to 50,000 euros. If the act is committed by someone who regularly practises a profession, the judgment is transmitted to the Order for the purposes of interdiction. The penalty is higher, from one to five years' imprisonment and from 15,000 to 75,000 euros in fines, for the professional who has induced others to commit the offence or has directed their activity. It is the rule that makes the boundary a serious matter for anyone running a practice.

The Code. At article 67 the Code prohibits the doctor from collaborating in any capacity with anyone unlawfully practising the profession, or from favouring them «by acting as a front man or omitting due supervision», and obliges the doctor to report to the Order any treatments carried out by unauthorised persons of which they become aware. The words «omitting due supervision» concern those who have assistants: supervising is an obligation, and it must be demonstrable.

The page on legal protection regarding who may do what also collects the Cassazione rulings on the subject, with the source for looking them up.

Responsibility

Italian Law 24/2017 (opens in a new tab) (article 7) says that a public or private healthcare facility that makes use of the work of health professionals, even those chosen by the patient and even if not employed by it, is liable for their wilful or negligent conduct. The practitioner is liable for their own acts. This means that those who work in the practice with you do not «remove» a responsibility from you: in the event of harm, the patient does not have to work out who did what in order to know whom to claim against. You, on the other hand, need to be able to reconstruct it.

What to write in the record when one part is carried out by others

Here the rule does not prescribe a form, but the logic is clear: if one part of the treatment is carried out by another person, the record must state who, with what qualification, and under which decision of the doctor. A list to keep to hand:

  • Who carried out the consultation and decided the treatment (name, qualification)
  • Who obtained consent (the doctor)
  • Who carried out each part of the treatment, with name and qualification
  • Who assisted
  • What prescription or instruction from the doctor there was
  • The product or device used, with batch or serial number
  • If another professional carried out a follow-up check, who

Fibonacci helps in two places. The patient team record is used to write down who follows the patient, with each person's role: it is a documentation note, and it neither grants nor removes access. The consent form carries the performing doctor, with professional order and registration number. Sessions are recorded in the treatment record, where product and batch remain written down.

A user with limited permissions

Permissions are a different layer from documentation. The practice administrator, from the members section, invites an assistant by choosing the role, and the dropdown writes next to each entry what that person sees. Some roles see all the practice's patients: administrator, doctor who sees everything, doctor for one site, head nurse, nursing staff, reception (patients and diary, without opening clinical records), cooperative reception. Others see only their own patients. If you have chosen the wrong role, a button changes the role without having to remove and re-invite: it applies from the next login and remains in the access log.

The role decides what a person may open. It does not decide what they may do in a treatment, and it does not make lawful what is not lawful by law. When an assistant leaves, access is removed with a button and ceases immediately, open sessions included; clinical data remain attributed to whoever wrote them. More details on the users and permissions page.

What Fibonacci does for this

This is how it looks in Fibonacci, with sample data:

The access log in Fibonacci, with sample data

Sources

  1. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, arts. 3, 13, 35, 66 and 67 (opens in a new tab)
  2. Italian Law 8 March 2017, no. 24 (Gelli-Bianco), art. 7 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Italian Criminal Code, art. 348 (unauthorised practice of a profession) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Regulation (EU) 2022/2346, Annexes IV and V (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles